{ "id": "RST-2026-0102", "kind": "result", "label": "Diagnostic: the measured 'quality' was format compliance on 2 of 3 tasks; verifier serialization failed 3/18; the A3/A4 rise is a missingness artifact", "created_at": "2026-09-03", "updated_at": "2026-09-07", "values": { "eml_status": "STABLE", "eml_evidence_level": "E2", "eml_object_version": "0.1", "eml_canonical_url": "https://evemisslab.com/ai/results/RST-2026-0102/", "eml_provenance": { "source": "EveMissLab research collection: Intelligence Physical Metrology (真本體論13)", "extracted_by": "Splice (Claude Code), reading the canonical UTF-8 sources and each package's own reports", "extracted_at": "2026-09-11", "generator": "tools/extract_all.py", "claim_boundary": "status, evidence level and result type follow the source artifact's own stated claim boundary; nothing is upgraded beyond what the report supports" }, "eml_summary": "Strict output-contract compliance 12/36 (MATH-003 12/12, CODE-001 0/12, CON-003 0/12), but the non-canonical post-hoc check finds every completed selected output correct — math 12/12 canonical correct, code 11/11 selected outputs pass all hidden tests after outer Markdown fence removal, constraint 10/10 selected outputs satisfy all constraints after format-only normalization — 33/33 overall. Verifier-enabled trials 18, verifier-protocol failures 3 (A3 2/6, A4 1/6, A5 0/6), each after eight candidates had been generated. Tool calls 0, retries 0; 24 candidates abandoned on abort are neither selected nor discarded in the schema. Quality availability is reported as 22/36 in the aggregate and 33/36 in protocol_compliance.csv. Telemetry sampling wall fraction 0.244.", "eml_summary_zh": "嚴格輸出契約合規 12/36（MATH-003 12/12、CODE-001 0/12、CON-003 0/12），但非 canonical 的事後檢查發現所有完成的選中輸出都正確——數學 12/12 canonical correct、程式 11/11 selected outputs pass all hidden tests after outer Markdown fence removal、約束 10/10 selected outputs satisfy all constraints after format-only normalization——整體 33/33。啟用驗證器的試驗 18 次，驗證器協定失敗 3 次（A3 2/6、A4 1/6、A5 0/6），每次都在已生成八個候選之後。工具呼叫 0 次、重試 0 次；24 個在中止時被拋棄的候選在 schema 裡既非選中也非丟棄。品質可得率在聚合檔報 22/36、在 protocol_compliance.csv 報 33/36。遙測取樣占 wall time 的 0.244。", "eml_label_zh": "診斷：三題中兩題量到的「品質」是格式服從性；驗證器序列化失敗 3/18；A3/A4 的上升是缺值假象", "eml_primary_domain": "Evaluation", "eml_program_id": "PRG-2026-0101", "eml_data_basis": "REAL MODEL", "eml_result_type": "NEGATIVE", "eml_metrics": { "strict_protocol_compliance": { "count": 12, "total": 36, "rate": 0.3333333333333333 }, "posthoc_semantic_diagnostic": { "canonical": false, "math": "12/12 canonical correct", "code": "11/11 selected outputs pass all hidden tests after outer Markdown fence removal", "constraint": "10/10 selected outputs satisfy all constraints after format-only normalization", "completed_selected_outputs_correct": "33/33" }, "verifier_failure": { "count": 3, "verifier_enabled_trials": 18, "rate": 0.16666666666666666, "by_condition": { "A3": "2/6", "A4": "1/6", "A5": "0/6" } }, "operational_totals": { "model_invocations": 186, "trajectories": 162, "retries": 0, "tool_calls": 0, "verifier_passes": 18, "candidates_created": 162, "candidates_selected": 33, "candidates_discarded": 105, "failure_events": 6, "candidates_abandoned_on_abort": 24 }, "quality_availability_reporting": { "aggregate_analysis": "22/36", "protocol_compliance_csv": "33/36", "inconsistency": true }, "instrumentation": { "mean_sampling_call_wall_fraction": 0.2436, "target_sampling_ms": 250, "observed_cadence_ms": "335–350" }, "instrument_revisions_required_before_XA-07": [ "R1 typed subject/system failure is valid data, separate from instrument failure", "R2 split task_semantic_quality / output_contract_compliance / system_completion_reliability / verifier_protocol_reliability", "R3 failure-aware aggregation (no survivor means)", "R4 abandoned-candidate accounting", "R5 preserve verifier parse diagnostics", "R6 cheaper telemetry (persistent nvidia-smi / NVML)", "R7 tool-trigger tasks" ] }, "eml_interpretation": "Negative for the instrument, informative for the theory. Task semantic quality ≠ protocol/serialization compliance — the model solved everything it completed and was scored 0.5 on average for not obeying a JSON/no-fence contract; same-model verification reduced system reliability rather than raising quality; tool access ≠ tool utilization (enabled, never used). The bundle stays immutable as XA-06 empirical v0.1; the next step is to revise the instrument and re-run a small validation set, not to re-roll failures until they disappear.", "eml_limitations": [ "The post-hoc semantic check is explicitly non-canonical and does not make the strict outputs compliant.", "One model; whether stronger models obey the output contract is unknown." ], "eml_ai_collaborators": [ "Aletheia (GPT-5.6 Sol, OpenAI ChatGPT) — 2026-09-07 diagnostic", "Splice (Claude Code, Anthropic) — execution and RESULT note" ], "eml_authors": [ "Neo.K (EveMissLab)" ] }, "canonical_url": "https://evemisslab.com/ai/results/RST-2026-0102/", "json": "/ai/results/RST-2026-0102/index.json", "relations": [ { "id": "REL-2026-0489", "predicate": "supports", "source": "RST-2026-0102", "target": "THY-2026-0106", "status": "ACTIVE" }, { "id": "REL-2026-0490", "predicate": "qualifies", "source": "RST-2026-0102", "target": "RST-2026-0101", "status": "ACTIVE" }, { "id": "REL-2026-0491", "predicate": "qualifies", "source": "RST-2026-0102", "target": "THY-2026-0109", "status": "ACTIVE" }, { "id": "REL-2026-0488", "predicate": "produces", "source": "EXP-2026-0103", "target": "RST-2026-0102", "status": "ACTIVE" } ], "snapshot": { "snapshot_id": "AI-SNAPSHOT-v0.1-fe85b9694a45", "created_at": "2026-09-11T05:00:27Z", "format_version": "0.1", "sedb_baseline": "v0.4B contract; static source content/ai/", "generator_version": "evemisslab-com ai_research 0.1", "object_count": 124, "relation_count": 499, "artifact_count": 58 } }