EVEMISSLAB

ClaimCLM-2026-0104v0.1

F4 — Scaffolding separation

If scaffolding does not change the structure of the capability source, SSR ≈ 1 should hold across most tasks and test-time compute budgets. If a large share of benchmark quality appears only under multi-sample, tool, verifier or loop conditions, the distinction between model-native and system capability is empirically necessary. First data point: three easy tasks on a local 9B model gave SSR = 1.0 — consistent with 'no gap' on tasks the native pass already solves, and uninformative beyond that because the quality axis was confounded by format compliance.

Research status
EXPERIMENTAL being tested experimentally
Evidence level
E2 Controlled experiment
Data basis
THEORY Theoretical reasoning only; no measurement.
Version
0.1
Updated
2026-09-02
Created
2026-09-02
Domain
Evaluation
Program
PRG-2026-0101 Intelligence Physical Metrology (IPM)
Authors
Neo.K (EveMissLab)
AI collaborators
Aletheia (GPT-5.6 Sol, OpenAI ChatGPT)

Recorded fields

falsification_conditions
  • Falsified for the separation's necessity if Q_F ≈ Q_SP holds across most tasks, models and budgets; supported if the gap is common. The 2026-09-03 pilot is one uninformative-to-weak point on the 'no gap' side.
tags
  • falsifiable proposition
  • IPM v0.1 canonical index §23
  • Paper 10

Relations

SourceRelationTargetStatusID
CLM-2026-0104 F4 — Scaffolding separationbelongs_toRES-2026-0103 Capability line — how much intelligence remains without the loop, and the unified intelligence eventACTIVEREL-2026-0386
THY-2026-0110 The canonical intelligence event, Pareto comparison and no premature scalarizationcontainsCLM-2026-0104 F4 — Scaffolding separationACTIVEREL-2026-0387
PAP-2026-0111 IPM v0.1 canonical index — series overview, unified notation and the v0.2 experimental entry pointformalizesCLM-2026-0104 F4 — Scaffolding separationACTIVEREL-2026-0441
PAP-2026-0110 Paper 10 — How much physical world does an answer cost? A unified metrology framework for intelligence yieldformalizesCLM-2026-0104 F4 — Scaffolding separationACTIVEREL-2026-0442
EXP-2026-0101 Experiment A — single-pass vs scaffolded controlled measurement (protocol v0.1)testsCLM-2026-0104 F4 — Scaffolding separationACTIVEREL-2026-0464
EXP-2026-0103 XA-06 first real-model pilot — Qwythos-9B-v2 on the A0→A5 ladder (36 trials, 2026-09-03)testsCLM-2026-0104 F4 — Scaffolding separationACTIVEREL-2026-0480
RST-2026-0101 Scaffolding response on three easy tasks: SSR = 1.0, 3.1× device energy at A5, 7.9–9.3× at A2–A4qualifiesCLM-2026-0104 F4 — Scaffolding separationACTIVEREL-2026-0487

History and provenance

Canonical URL
https://evemisslab.com/ai/claims/CLM-2026-0104/
Machine-readable
/ai/claims/CLM-2026-0104/index.json
Snapshot
AI-SNAPSHOT-v0.1-fe85b9694a45
Provenance
source
EveMissLab research collection: Intelligence Physical Metrology (真本體論13)
extracted_by
Splice (Claude Code), reading the canonical UTF-8 sources and each package's own reports
extracted_at
2026-09-11
generator
tools/extract_all.py
claim_boundary
status, evidence level and result type follow the source artifact's own stated claim boundary; nothing is upgraded beyond what the report supports