實驗EXP-2026-0004v0.1

R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate

AER-0 所有 canonical 寫入遷移到 Epistemic Commit Transaction（claim、evidence、provenance、有效／觀察時間、expected version、算子、驗證政策、權限、依賴、refresh policy）；直接 candidate commit 變成負向路徑。三套系統跑同一組治理見證：政策分散在各 caller 的應用、有單一集中強制 gate 的應用、AER-ECT。集中式應用 gate 在每個測試性質上都追平 AER-ECT；不支持計算獨特性。48 個測試。

研究狀態: STABLE 目前的研究結論相對穩定
證據等級: E2 受控實驗
結果: MIXED
資料基礎: DETERMINISTIC RUNTIME 在真實 runtime 裡執行的決定性情境；程式碼與做法都列出，數字是什麼就是什麼。
版本: 0.1
更新: 2026-09-08
建立: 2026-09-08
領域: AI Architecture, Evaluation, Agent Systems
計畫: PRG-2026-0001 自適應世界狀態系統的第一原理框架
作者: Neo.K (EveMissLab)
AI 協作: Sol (GPT-5.6, OpenAI ChatGPT)

假設

hypothesis: Binding evidence, provenance, verification, authority, expected version, temporal validity, dependencies and refresh policy into one mandatory canonical-mutation boundary is a new computational capability — or only an architectural elevation of existing mechanisms.

設定

software_environment: Python 3.11+, SQLite; no network, no external database, no LLM API required.

執行

run_count

controls

APP_CENTRALIZED_GATE is the fair strong opponent; APP_SCATTERED_POLICY is a mutation witness, not a claim about all applications.

metrics

verdict

ArchitecturalElevation SUPPORTED; ComputationalUniqueness NOT SUPPORTED

tests_passed

table

unprovenanced_write_blocked

scattered: FAIL
central_gate: PASS
aer_ect: PASS

stale_write_conflict_caught

scattered: FAIL
central_gate: PASS
aer_ect: PASS

automatic_audit

scattered: FAIL on mutated path
central_gate: PASS
aer_ect: PASS

single_governance_site

scattered: NO
central_gate: YES
aer_ect: YES

canonical_node_links_transaction

scattered: N/A
central_gate: optional
aer_ect: PASS

novelty

primitive: WEAK
transaction: WEAK
provenance: NONE claimed
versioning: NONE claimed
belief_revision: NONE claimed
temporal: NONE claimed
compositional: PLAUSIBLE / NOT PROVEN

詮釋

interpretation: Prior art (truth maintenance, transaction logic, agent knowledge-base transactions, W3C PROV, bitemporal data, PDP/PEP, age-of-information scheduling) covers every part. The value is 'there is only one legal write path' instead of 'remember to enforce policy everywhere' — an epistemically governed runtime, not a new computational species. A fair application that centralizes the same rules converges to the same form, which is itself an attractor witness.

限制

limitations: General performance, security advantage and real LangGraph executable equivalence NOT MEASURED.
Not an exhaustive novelty search; establishes no patent or publication novelty.

重現

reproduction_instructions: Extract the round's FINAL bundle; python -m pytest -q; python -m examples.research_assistant_demo; python -m benchmarks.<round benchmark>. Checksums in SHA256SUMS.txt.

結果

來源	關係	目標	狀態	ID
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`produces`	`RST-2026-0003` R3：AER-ECT ≈ 集中式應用 gate	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0134`

記錄欄位

completed_at: 2026-09-08

關係

來源	關係	目標	狀態	ID
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`runs_on`	`SYS-2026-0001` AER-0——自適應認識 runtime MVP	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0127`
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`uses_benchmark`	`BEN-2026-0002` AER-0 架構比較套件（R1–R6）	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0128`
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`tests`	`THY-2026-0006` AER-ECT：強制的認識論 commit 交易邊界	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0129`
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`tests`	`THY-2026-0002` Canonical 符號狀態與 candidate → verify → commit 權限	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0130`
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`tests`	`THY-2026-0003` 智能架構吸引子	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0131`
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`extends`	`EXP-2026-0003` R2——對 LangGraph 1.2.11 的 source-grounded 結構比較	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0132`
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`produced`	`ART-2026-0017` AER-0 MVP v0.1 Architecture Comparison R3 ECT `artifact://evemisslab/adaptive-epistemic-systems/AER-0_MVP_v0.1_Architecture_Comparison_R3_ECT.zip`	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0133`
`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`produces`	`RST-2026-0003` R3：AER-ECT ≈ 集中式應用 gate	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0134`
`EXP-2026-0005` R4——政策變異面：分散治理 vs 單一強制邊界	`extends`	`EXP-2026-0004` R3——認識論 commit 交易 vs 分散式與集中式應用 gate	`ACTIVE`	`REL-2026-0140`

歷史與來源歷程

Canonical URL

https://evemisslab.com/ai/experiments/EXP-2026-0004/

機器可讀

/ai/experiments/EXP-2026-0004/index.json

快照

AI-SNAPSHOT-v0.1-fe85b9694a45

來源歷程

source: EveMissLab research collection: Adaptive Epistemic Systems (真本體論13)
extracted_by: Splice (Claude Code), reading the canonical UTF-8 sources and each lab's own result reports
extracted_at: 2026-09-11
generator: tools/extract_aes/extract.py
claim_boundary: status, evidence level and result type follow the source artifact's own stated claim boundary; nothing is upgraded beyond what the report supports