研究RES-2026-0003v0.1
認識論治理能不能活過實作？AER-0 架構比較
六輪把 AER-0 runtime 與越來越強的基線比較——無狀態重算、固定 TTL、記憶 + 工具、事件驅動複合 agent、LangGraph 1.2.11（僅 source-grounded）、最後是一個允許做得跟 AER 一樣好的集中式應用層 gate。每一輪都把主張收窄：從「AER 不一樣」收到「AER 把認識論治理從應用慣例提升為 runtime 層的 canonical-write 邊界」，附有界中介與外部簽章真實性見證，並明確不主張獨特的計算能力。
研究問題
research_questions- When a baseline is given persistent memory, workflow reuse, event invalidation and versioning, how much of AER remains distinct?
- Is a mandatory epistemic commit transaction a new computational capability, or the elevation of convergent mechanisms into a runtime primitive?
- Can canonical epistemic mutation be completely mediated, and can authenticity be anchored outside the writable database?
主張
claims- R1: AER-0 is distinct on tested mutation semantics (provenance gate, optimistic version conflict) but not dominant — the evented baseline needs fewer recomputations.
- R3: AER-ECT ≈ centralized application gate on tested governance semantics; computational uniqueness NOT SUPPORTED; architectural elevation supported.
- R4: centralization reduces policy scattering (O(NR)→O(R)) and migration surface, at the price of a larger blast radius per shared defect.
- R5–R6: bounded complete mediation without tamperproofness; an Ed25519-signed external anchor converts a coherent full-DB forgery from undetected to detectable, given a trusted key and latest-head witness.
限制
limitations- No executable cross-runtime comparison: LangGraph could not be installed (PyPI DNS unavailable) in the R2 environment.
- No performance, cost, security-certification or general-intelligence claim; hostile same-process code and a compromised signer remain outside the trusted boundary.
關係
| 來源 | 關係 | 目標 | 狀態 | ID |
|---|---|---|---|---|
RES-2026-0003 認識論治理能不能活過實作？AER-0 架構比較 | belongs_to | PRG-2026-0001 自適應世界狀態系統的第一原理框架 | ACTIVE | REL-2026-0003 |
RES-2026-0003 認識論治理能不能活過實作？AER-0 架構比較 | extends | RES-2026-0001 自適應認識系統的盲推導 | ACTIVE | REL-2026-0005 |
RES-2026-0003 認識論治理能不能活過實作？AER-0 架構比較 | develops | THY-2026-0002 Canonical 符號狀態與 candidate → verify → commit 權限 | ACTIVE | REL-2026-0009 |
RES-2026-0003 認識論治理能不能活過實作？AER-0 架構比較 | develops | THY-2026-0003 智能架構吸引子 | ACTIVE | REL-2026-0011 |
RES-2026-0003 認識論治理能不能活過實作？AER-0 架構比較 | develops | THY-2026-0006 AER-ECT：強制的認識論 commit 交易邊界 | ACTIVE | REL-2026-0016 |
SYS-2026-0001 AER-0——自適應認識 runtime MVP | supports | RES-2026-0003 認識論治理能不能活過實作？AER-0 架構比較 | ACTIVE | REL-2026-0069 |
歷史與來源歷程
- Canonical URL
- https://evemisslab.com/ai/research/RES-2026-0003/
- 快照
AI-SNAPSHOT-v0.1-fe85b9694a45- 來源歷程
source- EveMissLab research collection: Adaptive Epistemic Systems (真本體論13)
extracted_by- Splice (Claude Code), reading the canonical UTF-8 sources and each lab's own result reports
extracted_at- 2026-09-11
generator- tools/extract_aes/extract.py
claim_boundary- status, evidence level and result type follow the source artifact's own stated claim boundary; nothing is upgraded beyond what the report supports